FAITH IN US: A faith and values column with Wesley Magruder

Losing one’s faith rarely happens in a single moment of time.
Instead, it’s a slow trickle of questions that won’t go away, frustrations with churches and pastors that are never addressed, certainties that crumble, and sparks of hope in places you were taught to mistrust.
One day, you wake up and realize that you don’t believe anymore.
That’s how it happened for me. Which is still surprising to me, since I served as a pastor and missionary for over 20 years. I’m at the tail end of a slow faith deconstruction. It feels like I’ve been pulling a long thread that has finally completely unraveled.
The first thing I lost was a fear of hell. That was a significant and healthy move, but difficult. I grew up in a fundamentalist charismatic cult which spent much too much time warning people about eternal torment. I remember how this horrified me as a 5 year old, and kept me awake many nights, even though I had prayed the requisite “sinner’s prayer” to keep me from going to hell. I prayed it over and over, hoping that I had said it with enough sincerity to make it true.
That thread was pulled when, as a young adult, I finally recognized that I couldn’t reconcile the image of a loving God with a God who sent people to a place of suffering for infinity. God had to be one or the other, but not both, no matter what the theologians say. I’d read it all, and kept coming to the same conclusion—the idea of a permanent hell is incompatible with the concept of a loving God.
And if God isn’t loving, then we’re all doomed.
In leaving the fundamentalism of my childhood, I thought I had pivoted to a more reasonable Christianity, something that was less simplistic and anti-intellectual. I made my way into a mainstream, moderate Protestant denomination, the United Methodist Church. In attending seminary at Perkins School of Theology at SMU in Dallas, I was introduced to a more solid Christianity, one that focused on grace, love, faith in action. This was something that seemed more solid and grounded.
Even so, I admit that there were doctrines I pledged to uphold that I found difficult to defend. For example, for years, the United Methodist Church had a line in its church doctrine which stated that “homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching,” forbidding pastors from performing same-sex unions, as well as banning gays and lesbians from becoming pastors. I openly disagreed with this doctrine, though I observed the letter of the law, until it was finally overturned a couple of years ago.
There were other threads I began to pull back in seminary, threads that asked, “Why did Jesus have to die?” and “Can the Bible really be trusted?” I knew all the standard and approved theological answers, but they didn’t do a good job of satisfying me.
But I soldiered on as a faithful, dutiful, ordained United Methodist pastor. I served as pastor for a string of churches in north Texas and England before taking a missionary assignment in Cameroon for four years. When our family returned to the States, I served another couple of churches in Dallas before accepting another missionary assignment, this time to South Africa, where I taught in a Methodist seminary.
When that assignment ended, after 20 years of service, I found myself on the edge of faith. This time it wasn’t just specific doctrines or beliefs that had brought me to the brink of disbelief. Instead, I had reached the end of my trust in religious institutions altogether.
Over my years of service to the church, I’ve been betrayed by colleagues, lied to, nearly head-butted, manipulated, yelled at, threatened, and laughed at. I’ve heard racist, misogynist, homophobic, fascist and anti-Christ language directed at me and others. I’ve had enough church trauma to never want to walk into one again.
My experience led me to the conclusion that, if this is where 2,000 years of accumulated tradition and passed-down Christianity has brought us, then I want nothing of it. As Jesus said, the tree is known by its fruit; bitter fruit means that the tree itself is rotten.
I decided to make a career shift at that time, and was hired to open a branch office of a global nonprofit in Wilmington in 2023. I still hadn’t completely separated myself from church; I even attended services at a local church when I moved to town.
But over time, the slow drip of faith exhaustion took its toll.
One day, I woke up and realized I just didn’t believe anymore. I had no patience to go over the doctrines I liked and the ones I didn’t; I didn’t want to go through the motions of attending worship. I was finished, done, kaput.
That’s been my headspace for the last couple of years. And in this time, I have felt myself breathe again. I don’t feel the pressure to defend or explain anything. I can just be.
And to be honest, only recently, have I started to feel something new begin to move deep inside. I don’t know what it is yet, but I have the feeling that it’s not “faith” itself that I lost, but all the systems and formulas and containers that this faith came in before.
I am beginning to reimagine something new and different, wild and liberating. It doesn’t look or sound like what I believed before. It doesn’t come in the same shapes and textures, but it’s there.
These days I write on Substack as The Post-Christian Pastor, sharing stories of my own deconstruction and offering advice and counsel to help folks reimagine a faith that works for them.
I’ve thought a lot about the role that religion used to play for me. I recognize that the primary function of religious faith for me had been to answer the basic questions of human existence, questions like:
“Who am I?”
“What is the purpose of my existence?”
“Where do I belong?”
“Why do I live and then die?”
“How can I be happy?”
I found answers to those questions through the framework of traditional Christianity. Until those answers didn’t work for me anymore. As the structure of my faith collapsed, I discovered that the questions remain. They are still there, tugging at me as ruthlessly as before.
The difference is that I don’t have quick, glib answers to them anymore. I don’t have the luxury of absolute certainty anymore.
But they didn’t go away.
I’m no longer scared of them. I know that every single one of us struggles to answer them. Because of that, I believe that confronting life’s existential questions is one arena that can serve as a common ground for human community and solidarity.
We all are born into the same existential dilemma; we all start life with these questions about identity, meaning, connection, happiness, mortality. We all are confronted with the same questions.
Religion comes after that; so does philosophy and politics, culture and the arts. These are all attempts to answer these burning questions at the heart of it all.
Some people find religious faith to be extremely helpful in this project as I once did, but many of the rest of us don’t. Or at least not in the form that religious faith was presented to us.
I’ve been invited to write a regular column for encore magazine, because there are lots and lots of you out there who find yourselves in a similar position to me. You may have grown up in the church, or joined at a later age, only to discover that it didn’t work for you. Perhaps the church embraced positions on political or social issues that you disagreed with; maybe you found yourself being abused by people in power, or perhaps the church made you feel like you didn’t belong, wasn’t worthy, or couldn’t measure up. Or maybe going to church didn’t feel like it was contributing to your mental and emotional wellbeing.
I felt all of those things—as a pastor! My faith deconstruction has been hastened by all of these experiences. I am here to say that I hear you. I understand what these traumas have done to you. I want to acknowledge and affirm your pain.
I can also say that once I let go of the faith that I’d carried with me for so long, I found a new freedom, an openness to something transcendent, something spiritual (if I may be allowed to use such a contested word). I no longer think in terms of “what I believe” and “what I don’t believe,” but rather in what I have encountered for myself in the depths of my soul.
Those encounters can’t really be put into words, doctrines, or dogmas. They can’t be encapsulated in theological textbooks or put into easily repeatable formulas.
But they are worth paying attention to. These are the experiences that give us life, hope, joy. They are the things worth living for. Even if they don’t completely answer any of the basic existential questions.
And that’s the kind of faith I’m looking for—a faith that makes life quiver with the tremors of delight.




